.jpg?v=d7f1b62159b21f52fe14df30fdc0f34b)
Excluding children from school 'may do more harm than good'
A new study has offered evidence that excluding children from school as a disciplinary tool may do more harm than good.
Research from the University of Exeter has revealed that exclusion from school can do damage to a pupil's mental health, resulting in a negative cycle that amplifies their disruptive behaviour rather than solve it.
Examining data from 5,000 school-aged children, their parents and their teachers, it was found that children with learning difficulties and mental health problems, such as depression, anxiety, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and autism spectrum conditions, are more likely to be excluded from the classroom.
Moreover, this association was shown to be bidirectional, meaning that children with psychological distress and mental health problems were more likely to be excluded in the first place, but also that exclusion was associated with increased levels of psychological distress three years later.
As such, it was suggested that children who struggle or act disruptively in class should be identified and provided with tailored support to help them improve, as this will have a much more positive long-term outcome for students and teachers alike than exclusion.
Professor Tamsin Ford, a child and adolescent psychiatrist at the University of Exeter's Medical School, said: "For children who really struggle at school, exclusion can be a relief as it removes them from an unbearable situation, with the result that on their return to school they will behave even more badly to escape again.
"As such, it becomes an entirely counterproductive disciplinary tool as for these children it encourages the very behaviour that it intends to punish."
Exclusion from school is known to be more common among boys, secondary school pupils and those living in socioeconomically deprived circumstances. Consistently poor behaviour in the classroom is the main reason for school exclusion.
Sign up to posts
Related jobs
Salary
£13.75 - 14.50 per hour
Location free text
St Austell
Job Type
Full Time
Salary
£10 - £19 per hour
Sector
Teaching Assistant
Location
St Austell
Description
Position = AP Teaching AssistantPay: £13.75-£14.50Location: St AustellStart Date: 3rd September 2025End Date: 23rd July 2026Expected interview Date: 14th July 2025Qualifications/ Desired Experience:•E
Reference
LR0003
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Cornwall Secondary & SENAuthor
Cornwall Secondary & SENSalary
£25 - 35 per hour
Location free text
North Yorkshire
Job Type
Flexible Working
Salary
£20 - £29 per hour
£30 per hour and above
Sector
Tutor/Intervention
Location
North Yorkshire
Description
Are you passionate about helping children in care thrive through personalised, 1:1 education? We are seeking a dedicated, adaptable LAC Tutor to provide high-quality, targeted academic support to Look
Reference
EPLacNY
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
North East TuitionAuthor
North East TuitionSalary
£25 - 35 per hour
Location free text
Hedge End
Job Type
Full Time
Salary
£100 - £199 per day
£200 - £299 per day
£20 - £29 per hour
£30 per hour and above
Sector
English
Location
Hampshire
Description
Become a Tutor in Hampshire with TP Tutors for the new academic year!Inspire. Support. Empower.Are you based in Hampshire and passionate about helping young people succeed?TP Tutors is looking for fl
Reference
Hampshire2
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
South TuitionAuthor
South TuitionSalary
£25 - 35 per hour
Location free text
North Yorkshire
Job Type
Flexible Working
Salary
£20 - £29 per hour
£30 per hour and above
Sector
Tutor/Intervention
Location
North Yorkshire
Description
Do you have a passion for making a difference in the lives of young people who need support outside of mainstream education? We are seeking a committed, creative, and resilient Alternative Provision P
Reference
EPNYAP
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
North East TuitionAuthor
North East TuitionSalary
£90 - 140 per day
Location free text
Northamptonshire
Job Type
Full Time
Salary
Less than £100 per day
£100 - £199 per day
Sector
Secondary
Location
Northamptonshire
Description
Job Title: Behaviour Support Specialists – September 2025 Start Location: Secondary Schools Across Northamptonshire Contract Type: Full-time, Part-time, and Flexible Supply Roles Available Salary: Com
Reference
behaviourspecialist
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Salary
£90 - 150 per day
Location free text
Northamptonshire
Job Type
Flexible Working
Salary
Less than £100 per day
£100 - £199 per day
Sector
Cover Supervisor
Location
Northamptonshire
Description
Job Title: General Day-to-Day Supply Teachers – September 2025 Start Location: Secondary Schools Across Northamptonshire Contract Type: Flexible Daily Supply / Short-Term Cover Salary: Competitive dai
Reference
GeneralSupply
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Salary
£90 - 150 per day
Location free text
Northamptonshire
Job Type
Flexible Working
Salary
Less than £100 per day
£100 - £199 per day
Sector
Physical Education
Location
Northamptonshire
Description
Job Title: PE Supply Teachers (Male & Female) – September 2025 Start Location: Various Secondary Schools Across Northamptonshire Contract Type: Full-time, Part-time, and Long-term Supply Opportunities
Reference
PESUPPLY
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Salary
£90 - 150 per day
Location free text
Northampton
Job Type
Flexible Working
Salary
Less than £100 per day
£100 - £199 per day
Sector
Modern foreign languages
Location
Northampton
Description
Job Title: French & Spanish Supply Teachers – September 2025 Start Location: Various Secondary Schools Across Northamptonshire Contract Type: Full-time, Part-time, and Long-term Supply Opportunities A
Reference
MFLSUPPLY
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Salary
£25,500 - 35,470 per year
Location free text
Northamptonshire
Job Type
Full Time
Salary
£20,000 - £29,999
£30,000 - £39,999
Sector
Secondary
Location
Northamptonshire
Description
Aspiring Teachers – September Start Launch Your Teaching Career in NorthamptonshireAre you a recent graduate or soon-to-be graduate with a passion for education? Do you dream of making a difference i
Reference
teachergrad
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Salary
£25 - 30 per hour
Location free text
Bromley
Job Type
Flexible Working
Salary
£20 - £29 per hour
Sector
Tutor/Intervention
Location
Bromley
Description
Are you ready to make a meaningful impact on young lives? Do you have experience working within an SEN environment & are looking for a new challenge? TP-Tutors is on the lookout for tutors with SEN ex
Reference
HOSENBromley0807
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Related posts

Teaser
Special Educational NeedsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD07YY
Summary
In December 2024, the government announced new specialist places in mainstream schools to better support pupils with Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND). Yet, staff shortages limit s

Teaser
Special Educational NeedsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD06YY
Summary
Recent statistics highlight gaps in SEND (Special Educational Needs and Disabilities) training and support for educators. The government wants more SEND pupils in mainstream schools. At the same t

Teaser
Special Educational NeedsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD06YY
Summary
In 2024, the National Audit Office (NAO) highlighted the crisis in the SEND system, noting limited progress in making mainstream schools more inclusive. Without further investment and changes, t

Teaser
Special Educational NeedsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD06YY
Summary
How to navigate SEND funding for 2025-26 As government funding for special education needs and disabilities (SEND) evolves, schools face critical challenges securing essential resources. Sch

Teaser
Special Educational NeedsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD06YY
Summary
Unpacking SEND reform: Where are we now and what’s coming next? A rapid rise in pupils diagnosed with autistic spectrum disorder, social, emotional, and mental health needs (including ADHD), as

Teaser
Education NewsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD05YY
Summary
What do schools need to know this term? Change is constant in the education sector, and this term is no different. From Ofsted and pay reviews, to structural shifts like RISE and curriculum refo
by
Zuzana Vrtalova

Teaser
Tips and AdviceContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD03YY
Summary
The True Worth of Professional Exam Invigilation When schools and colleges across England and Wales prepare for examination periods, the pressure to maintain JCQ compliance while ensuring fair ass
by
Zuzana Vrtalova

Teaser
EducatorsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD03YY
Summary
With the Easter break and end of term coming up, it’s time to get your payroll sorted! Our Payroll team has outlined the key dates you need to ensure you receive your pay on time. Check out the ta
by
Zuzana Vrtalova

Teaser
Special Educational NeedsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD03YY
Summary
The landscape of Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) is transforming. The number of pupils in the UK with special educational needs (SEN) has increased over the last five years. Toda
by
Adam Davies

Teaser
EducatorsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD02YY
Summary
As Spring approaches, it's a critical date for many teachers in the UK who may be contemplating their professional future ahead of the February 28th resignation deadline. While teaching remains on
by
Adam Davies
Register with us
for a choice of classroom roles
Register today
Recent job