Year-by-year fluctuations in exam results 'should be seen as normal'
Schools, assessors and policymakers should be more accepting of the fact that year-to-year variations in exam attainment levels among pupils should be seen as normal and predictable.
This is according to a new report from Cambridge Assessment, which has offered evidence that a certain degree of volatility in schools' GCSE results is quantifiable and inevitable, due to changes in the overall ability level of the student body in any given year, as well as simple chance.
For this research, GCSE performance data from between 2011 and 2015 was taken from the Department for Education's National Pupil Database, with statistical models used to estimate how much of the national variation in results could be explained by differences between schools, differences between years at the same schools, and differences between pupils within each cohort.
Once students' typical academic performance was added into their models, the size of the predicted year-to-year fluctuations was very nearly as large as those seen in practice, showing that the majority of volatility can be explained by normal variation in students' ability levels.
The researchers say these trends occur even if teaching practices remain the same, and is an unavoidable consequence of the fact that a different set of individuals take the exams each year. Accepting this can help schools to better understand the full range of performance outcomes that may occur.
They concluded: "Because there is chance involved, and because schools and their students change over time, it is natural that schools would see different results from one year to the next.
"The most important thing is that as a teacher, you don't know what mix of abilities you'll get in a particular class each year. Recognising this ensures we have realistic expectations of our education and assessment system."
Sign up to posts
Related jobs
Salary
£20 - 29 per hour
Location free text
Daventry
Job Type
Flexible Working
Salary
£20 - £29 per hour
Sector
Tutor/Intervention
Location
Northamptonshire
Description
1:1 Tutor – Daventry Location: Daventry and surrounding areas Hours: Flexible, during school hours Pay: Competitive rates (dependent on experience and qualifications)Are you an experienced teacher lo
Reference
S350/Daventry
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Central TuitionAuthor
Central TuitionSalary
£20 - 29 per hour
Location free text
Peterborough
Job Type
Flexible Working
Salary
£20 - £29 per hour
Sector
Tutor/Intervention
Location
Peterborough
Description
1:1 Tutor – Peterborough Location: Peterborough and surrounding areas Hours: Flexible, during school hours Pay: Competitive rates (dependent on experience and qualifications)Are you an experienced ed
Reference
S347/Peterborough
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Central TuitionAuthor
Central TuitionSalary
£20 - 29 per hour
Location free text
Northampton
Job Type
Flexible Working
Salary
£20 - £29 per hour
Sector
Tutor/Intervention
Location
Northampton
Description
1:1 Tutor – Northamptonshire Location: Northamptonshire Hours: Flexible, during school hours Pay: Competitive rates (dependent on experience and qualifications)Are you an experienced educator with a
Reference
S346/Northampton
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Central TuitionAuthor
Central TuitionSalary
£32k - 47k per year
Location free text
Rochdale
Job Type
Full Time
Salary
£30,000 - £39,999
£40,000 - £49,999
Sector
Geography
Location
Rochdale
Description
Geography Teacher – Rochdale (September 2026 Start)Are you a passionate and qualified Geography teacher seeking an exciting new opportunity for 2026? If so, this could be the perfect role for you.A
Reference
RochGeog
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Manchester North SecondaryAuthor
Manchester North SecondarySalary
£90 - 100 per day
Location free text
Oldham
Job Type
Full Time
Salary
Less than £100 per day
£100 - £199 per day
Sector
Teaching Assistant
Location
Oldham
Description
Are you an experienced Teaching Assistant looking for your next opportunity in a supportive and forward-thinking secondary school? We are working closely with a number of well-established schools ac
Reference
TAS350928OLD
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Manchester North SecondaryAuthor
Manchester North SecondarySalary
£140 - 170 per day
Location free text
Greater Manchester
Job Type
Full Time
Salary
£100 - £199 per day
Sector
Other
Location
Greater Manchester
Description
Teaching Personnel are actively recruiting Early Career Teachers (ECTs) for flexible supply teaching opportunities across Oldham and Rochdale. These roles are perfect for ECTs looking to gain valuab
Reference
239047208374234
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Manchester North SecondaryAuthor
Manchester North SecondarySalary
£100 - 120 per day
Location free text
Rubery
Job Type
Flexible Working
Salary
£100 - £199 per day
£10 - £19 per hour
Sector
Cover Supervisor
Location
West Midlands
Description
Cover Supervisor – South Birmingham (B45 Area) Location: South Birmingham (B45 and surrounding areas) Salary: Competitive daily rate Job Type: Full-time / Part-time / Flexible SupplyWe are seeking co
Reference
Cover Supervisor
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Birmingham SecondaryAuthor
Birmingham SecondarySalary
£100 - 120 per day
Location free text
Rochdale
Job Type
Full Time
Salary
£100 - £199 per day
£10 - £19 per hour
Sector
Cover Supervisor
Location
Rochdale
Description
Teaching Personnel are recruiting a dedicated Cover Supervisor to work within a well-established secondary school in Rochdale. This role offers consistent work with the possibility of a long-term pl
Reference
9-5285091374543
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Manchester North SecondaryAuthor
Manchester North SecondarySalary
£100 - 120 per day
Location free text
Oldham
Job Type
Full Time
Salary
£100 - £199 per day
£10 - £19 per hour
Sector
Cover Supervisor
Location
Oldham
Description
Teaching Personnel are currently working with a number of secondary schools across Oldham who are seeking confident and adaptable Cover Supervisors to support with day-to-day and long-term absences.
Reference
439732094732489
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Manchester North SecondaryAuthor
Manchester North SecondarySalary
£32,916 - 51,048 per year
Location free text
Bristol
Job Type
Part Time
Salary
£100 - £199 per day
£200 - £299 per day
Sector
Drama
Location
Bristol
Description
Performing Arts Teacher (0.6) Bristol Part-Time (0.6) | Permanent Start Date: September 2026 Key Stages 3, 4 / 5I am recruiting alongside a highly successful and oversubscribed secondary school i
Reference
8/6 PAT EH
Expiry Date
DD01YY
Author
Bristol SecondaryAuthor
Bristol SecondaryRelated posts
Teaser
EducatorsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD05YY
Summary
Exams are one of the most stressful times in the academic year, and it isn’t only pupils who feel the pressure. For teaching assistants (TAs) and support staff, exam season brings new expectations
by
Adam Davies
Teaser
EducatorsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD05YY
Summary
If you’re considering taking the next step in education, you’re not alone. More teachers and support staff are exploring permanent roles that offer stability, progression, and a sense of belonging
by
Adam Davies
Teaser
People & CultureContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD05YY
Summary
As Teaching Personnel marks 30 years, Danielle shares her experience of building a career with the company over the past 11 years. She's completed an apprenticeship, managed a branch and w
Teaser
People & CultureContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD04YY
Summary
Patrick highlights a decade of his work as Teaching Personnel celebrates a milestone of 10 years.He's built relationships with schools and his own management style to successfully run a branch
Teaser
People & CultureContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD04YY
Summary
As Teaching Personnel celebrates 30 years, we hear from Senior Branch Manager, Hannah James, who reflects on her time with us these past 11 years. The impact we have on our schools and educat
Teaser
People & CultureContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD04YY
Summary
As Teaching Personnel marks 30 years, Vicky shares her experience of building a career with the company over the past 11 years.She joined as a trainee recruitment consultant and has become an
Teaser
People & CultureContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD04YY
Summary
As we celebrate 30 years of making difference, get to know Rebecca who has worked at Teaching Personnel for nearly a decade. Being able to support schools and help place the right educators
Teaser
People & CultureContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD04YY
Summary
As Teaching Personnel celebrates its 30-year anniversary, Jenny reflects on a decade of working at Teaching Personnel.From starting as a teaching assistant to overseeing multiple branches, her
Teaser
EducatorsContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD04YY
Summary
Gemma joined the Future Teachers Programme shortly after graduating. Now in a permanent teaching position, she reflects on how the programme shaped her classroom experience and supp
Teaser
People & CultureContent Type
TP-PostsPublish date
DD04YY
Summary
Discover Ben Whittle’s role and find out about his impact within the Future Teachers Programme Read more How long have you been with Teaching Personnel and where are
Register with us
for work in schools across England & Wales
Register today
Recent job